Category Archives: Help To Buy

Observations, news and views regarding the controversial government Help-to-Buy schemes.

Help to Buy scheme advertised on television.

“Dream of owning your own home but need a little help?”                       Not content with creating another housing bubble – Nationwide report house prices have risen 8.8% since January 2013 – HM government is now advertising its Help To Buy scheme on the television with a taxpayer-funded 30 second commercial.  You can see it here! 

Why?   Surely people who cannot afford to buy their own home, should not be persuaded to buy by the government?   It’s a bit like payday lending for home buyers. They know they cannot afford it but hey, the government is making it easy, so why not? 

Help To Buy jpgThe advertisement says the scheme is for “People who can afford a mortgage, but not a big deposit”   So it’s for people who cannot afford to save 5% – 10% of the purchase price – the very same people who will struggle to meet the monthly repayments when interest rates eventually go up.   To buy the average UK home costing £176,500 a buyer(s) would need to be earning at least £42,000 based on a mortgage of four times earnings. Surely someone earning over £40,000 a year (£31,300 a year – £2,610 a month after tax and NI) should be able to save a sizeable deposit in a few years? After all, it is just a question of priorities. 

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Help to Buy a helping hand to another house price bubble and crash

The coalition’s Help to Buy scheme is nothing short of taxpayer-funded electioneering. The only people who openly have a good word to say for it are politicians, house builders and estate agents. Everyone else can see it for the cynical disaster in waiting it is. With an election in 17 months time, the government is hell bent on helping house prices rise until then.  Any economic growth will be based on debt, as home owners feel better off due to rising property prices and start spending again – it is the same old story. But this time, it will be the British taxpayer left without a chair to sit on when the (low interest rate) music stops. 

P1000335Help to Buy (1) Equity Share, subsidises the cost of new homes by up to 20% and has even boosted the prices of older homes as it gave the market a psychological shot in the arm.   It is said that Help to Buy is only supposed to be a temporary measure, designed to help people buy a home until the banks start lending again, but the evidence is that they already are!   Help to Buy (2) Mortgage Indemnity, is not really needed, it will make very little difference to mortgage availability and does nothing except give the lenders an additional 15% comfort zone for potential losses on loans they would have given anyway, all at the expense of the taxpayer. 

Help to Buy (1) has resulted in house builders building more homes. Why wouldn’t they?   They have a ready supply of subsidised buyers, they are reporting record reservations and profits whilst increasing average selling prices, some by as much as 11% in the last 6 months, without any loss of demand. 

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Persimmon and Bovis benefit from Help to Buy

Help to Buy GraphicblogPersimmon has confirmed it has sold over 3,000 new homes under the government’s Help to Buy Equity Loan scheme launched in April. This  equating to approximately a third of the group’s total completions in 2012.

The second, and more controversial, part of Help to Buy was brought forward and launched in October, offering indemnity guarantees to lenders for their 95% mortgages for new and existing homes. Many are saying the scheme risks causing a housing bubble. 

Persimmon confirmed that the impact of Help to Buy (2) mortgage indemnity, had “been muted due to the higher level of interest rates being charged with only a limited number of lenders involved in this second phase so far.” They anticipate that sales supported by these guaranteed mortgages will increase as interest rates begin to reduce as more lenders enter the market over the next few months.  

In a statement Persimmon said: “We believe mortgages associated with the Help to Buy equity loan scheme will remain the preferred choice for the majority of customers of the house building industry given that interest rates for this product are significantly more competitive than those available with the Government guarantee.” 

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

George Osborne says Help to Buy unlikely to affect house prices

Despite a widespread condemnation of the Help to Buy scheme and an already overheating property market, George Osborne has now gone on record stating that “the Office for Budget responsibility has estimated that during the three years the scheme will be running, there will be over 3.4 million property transactions. Of these only 2% will be with the support of the Help to Buy Equity Loan scheme and therefore it is unlikely that the scheme will have a material effect on house prices.” 

Help To Buy jpgHowever, during the first five months of the scheme, over 12,000 households have already reserved a new home using the Help to Buy Equity Loan scheme. At the current rate of take up there will be 18,400 more buyers using the Equity Loan scheme, 27% more than Mr Osborne’s forecast. With house builder’s average prices rising around 7.6% over the last 12 months and outstripping price rises in the general housing market, as house prices get even further out of reach, even more buyers will need to use the Help to Buy Shared Equity Scheme. 

BubbleReaders should note that Mr Osborne specifically avoided saying that the recently brought forward Help to Buy Mortgage Guarantee scheme will not lead to a house price bubble.

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Help to Buy Mortgage Guarantee

Yesterday, the government officially launched the Help to Buy Mortgage Guarantee along with details of lender’s fees and some 66 pages of scheme rules.

house-of-moneyThe £12billion scheme is intended to help thousands of people buy a home. RBS, NatWest and Halifax will start taking applications this week, with HSBC and Virgin Money joining later. However, some bankers working on the scheme say they expect interest rates could be as high as 6%, well above the best deals currently available, due to government fees. Buyers can already get 95% mortgages by paying a rate of around 6%.

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

David Cameron announces Help to Buy to be brought forward

David Cameron has announced, ahead of the Conservative conference in Manchester, that the second phase of the controversial ‘Help to Buy’ scheme is to be brought forward by three months and will be available from 7th October 2013. This comes despite numerous criticisms and warnings from many top economic experts that Help to Buy will create and fuel another house price bubble.

house-of-moneyHe rejected these concerns, including those of his Business Secretary Vince Cable of the prospect of an unsustainable boom in house prices, particularly in the south-east of England. Speaking in Manchester, David Cameron said: “talk of a housing bubble to people here in Manchester or Salford, and they would literally laugh in your face”. He also claimed that the number of first time buyers is still almost half what it was before the financial crisis and the number of mortgage approvals is still well below pre credit crunch levels.

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Redrow Steve Morgan dismisses Help to Buy bubble as “silly”

Steve Morgan CEO of house builder Redrow has dismissed the view that current government mortgage schemes were fuelling the housing boom saying that UK’s “bureaucratic mess” of an “antiquated planning system” was the main cause of the housing shortage. 

The government has been criticised by economists and industry players for its launch of the ‘Help to Buy’ scheme in March, the first part of which provides shared equity loans to help people to buy a new home with a deposit of just 5%. P1000470“I’ve seen some pretty silly things written in the last week or two and stated by certain politicians,” said chief execultive Steve Morgan recently, careful to avoid naming anyone in particular.   “The real issue is not whether Help to Buy is fuelling a new boom, the real issue is that we’re not building enough houses, and we’re not building enough houses because we’ve got an antiquated planning system.”   

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Evidence that Help to Buy is helping house builders more than buyers

The larger listed house builders have reported accelerated demand for their new David Wilson Homes Sold Boardhomes, with sales, reservations and profit considerably higher so far this year. First half forward reservations are up an average 36% on the same period last year with average revenues and profits are up 13% and 40% respectively. 

Bovis Sales OfficeHelp to Buy has without doubt significantly contributed to the increase in reservations since it was introduced in April, with around 12,500 homes reserved as a result of the scheme, accounting for around a quarter of each house builder’s sales so far this year. 

Barratt CEO Mark Clare said recently: “We have had people coming at 4am for a 9am start and have many examples where our sales teams have arrived to find a dozen or so people waiting. We are starting to see queues, which is not something we have seen for years. And we are also seeing people buying off plan, which we have not seen for five or six years.”  

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

House builders report profit rises due to Help to Buy

Help To Buy jpgAll is rosy for the house builders as they continue to pig out and increase their profits due to Help to Buy, the government’s taxpayer-funded subsidy for the house building industry.

Barratt announce profits up 72% and average selling price up 8%

Ahead of their end of year financing report, Barratt released a trading statement on 10 July 2013 stating that the number of completions to 30 June 2013 is forecast to be 13,663 – up 16.1% on last year. With the average selling price up 8% to £192,000, it is not surprising Barratt are anticipating operating profit (“before exceptional items”) to be up 32% to £252 million (10.4%) and profit before tax up a massive 72% on last year to £192million (9.7%) on sales of £2,605 million.  Barratt stated:

“that since the launch of Help to Buy on 1 April, net private reservations per active site per week were up 34.7% on the prior year” “We are targeting Group completion volumes of c. 16,000 units (including JVs) from our current structure, and recognise this may be achieved more quickly than previously anticipated reflecting the benefit of the Help to Buy scheme.”

Barratt have around 380 active developments nationally.

Taylor Wimpey report a 42% rise in profit and 7% rise in average selling prices

Yesterday, Taylor Wimpey reported first half 42% rise in profit before tax of £143.1 million, up from £99.1 million a year earlier. Despite only building only 5191 new homes up just 108 in the H1 period, their average selling price is up 6.8% to £188,000 (from £176,000) on the same period a year ago.

Taylor Wimpey also announced an interim dividend of 0.22p a share, up 16% from 0.19p a year ago.

Continue reading

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Call for a Windfall Tax on House Builders

Why we must levy a windfall tax on house builders

Along with many financial experts we are of the opinion that George Osborne’s “Help To Buy” scheme will fuel a house price bubble – in fact it already is!

It is nothing short of a subsidy for house builders who continue to make record profits, most of whom report profits up 50% or more last year even before help to buy kicked in. Help To Buy has enabled house builders to avoid reducing prices and provide lenders with less risk on loans. 

The treasury estimates that the £3.5billion scheme will help up to 74,000 new home buyers.  I am of the opinion that the house builders are the main beneficiaries.

Barratt Share Price 1

Those buying a new home will be buying just 80%, paying ever-increasing prices. The house builder’s shares are at record levels as the Help To Buy bonanza is enabling them to pig out on naive buyers who cannot really afford to own a home. Described by Albert Edwards of Societe Generale as “the indentured servitude of our young people”

The government must therefore levy a windfall tax on all house builders making in excess of a 10% profit whilst the scheme is in operation, to prevent house builders cashing in on the extra demand and raising their prices as financing a new home becomes easier.

When interest rates eventually do rise and there is a corresponding house price crash, it will be the taxpayer, left without a chair when the music stops! 

Quite frankly, Help To Buy is nothing short of a political measure to give the illusion of prosperity in time for the 2015 election. Provided the bubble doesn’t burst before the next election, the government doesn’t care!

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter